Push vs email vs SMS. Three channels, three jobs.
They are not rivals. Each one reaches a different group of shoppers and suits a different kind of message. Here is how to tell which to use, and when.
The same message, three waysPush asks for one tap, then shows on the screen.
- PushNeedsOne tap on AllowLands on their screen
- EmailNeedsAn email addressLands in their inbox
- SMSNeedsA phone numberLands in their text messages
It starts with what the shopper gives you. That decides who you can reach.
Push
The shopper gives youOne tap on "Allow"So you can reachVisitors you do not know yet, with no form to fill in.Email
The shopper gives youTheir email addressSo you can reachPeople who signed up or bought from you before.SMS
The shopper gives youTheir phone number, and clear consentSo you can reachPeople who trust you enough to share a number.
Most visitors leave a store without typing an email or a phone number. One tap is a much smaller ask, so push can reach shoppers the other two never see.
Which channel fits the job? Pick one and see.
Best fit for this jobPush
- PushReaches them with no email and no phone number.Best fit
- EmailOnly works if they typed an email before leaving.Also possible
- SMSOnly works if you have their number and consent.Also possible
Three lanes, side by side. No winner. Each has its own job.
| Push | SMS | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| What the shopper gives you | One tap on "Allow" | Their email address | Their phone number and clear consent |
| Who you can reach | Visitors you do not know yet | People who signed up or bought | People who shared a number |
| Where it shows up | On the screen, on desktop or phone | In the inbox | In text messages |
| How much you can say | A title, a short line, an image and two buttons | As much as you like | A short text and a link |
| What it costs | Part of your PingLane plan, from $0 | Depends on your email tool, often on list size | You pay for every text |
| Best at | Timely nudges: carts, restocks, price drops, sales | Long content, receipts and relationships | Urgent, personal updates |
| Keep in mind | The shopper must stay opted in on that browser. On iPhone, the store must be added to the Home Screen first. | A crowded inbox, and promotions or spam folders. | Strict consent rules in many countries, and it is easy to overdo. |
They work best together. One shopper, three channels.
- First visitThey tap AllowYou have no email yet. A welcome notification says hello.Push
- An hour laterThey leave a cartA reminder brings them back to checkout.Push
- At checkoutThey buyNow you have their email. The receipt and follow-ups go to the inbox.Email
- Delivery dayThe package arrivesA text, or a push with Shopify Flow, tells them it is on the doorstep.SMS or push
PingLane does one of the three. Keep the tools you have for the other two.
PingLane sends web push only. It works next to your email and SMS apps, and reaches the visitors they cannot: the ones who never typed an address or a number.
- Free plan with every feature, no credit card
- Cart, browse, restock and price drop automations ready
- Nothing to change in your email or SMS setup
Push, email and SMS questions. Common questions.
Still have a question?Chat with us from the bottom corner. A real person replies.
Neither is better. Push reaches visitors who never gave an email. Email reaches people you already know and has room for long content. Many stores use both.
No. Push works on its own. A shopper taps Allow and you can reach them, with no form and no address.
No. PingLane sends web push only. Keep the email and SMS tools you already use, and use PingLane for push.
Push is a good first step, because any visitor can say yes with one tap and no email address. Email gets stronger as your list grows.
Not if each one has its own job. Use push for timely nudges, email for longer messages and receipts, and SMS for the few updates that are truly urgent.
